In response to media queries concerning the proposal between five EU countries and Rwanda, UN High Commissioner for Human Rights Volker Türk says:
We know how difficult, politicised, and polarising migration issues have become.
While we are not privy to the text of the proposal, we are concerned about the human rights risks raised by the proposed transfer of people from five European Union countries to Rwanda, where they have no genuine connection and which has its own set of human rights challenges.
The solution does not lie in single measures – often very costly – of finding countries far away to deal with one aspect of migration governance, or in externalising human rights obligations.
The response lies in a deeper analysis of the drivers behind migration, which include various human rights challenges, huge inequalities in many parts of the world, an inequitable economic and financial system that disadvantages many countries in the Global South, a surge in violent conflicts, and heightened geopolitical tensions.
These need to be tackled head-on and with determination, including through adequate investments that address these drivers and create viable opportunities at home.
At the same time, societies in the Global North are rapidly ageing, grappling with labour shortages in important areas and the sustainability of their social protection systems.
All of this requires a comprehensive approach to migration governance anchored in human rights, including through the expansion of regular migration pathways, and with recognition of the enormous contributions of migrants to European societies and economies.
